Tuesday, 5 April 2016

Legalising building fraud will lead to disaster- High Court





The Bombay High Court, while hearing petitions seeking to legalise illegal structures in various parts of the city, has ruled that Regularization of unauthorized constructions will have to be permitted on a case-to-case basis and should not be granted as a matter of course.

A division bench of the High Court held that the planning authority had to consider various factors such as infrastructure, congestion, water supply, and roads before regularizing illegal constructions against payment of a penalty.  If there is an increasing pressure and burden on the existing facilities and amenities then the whole system would collapse resulting in large-scale inconvenience, it was observed. 

The cases before the Hon'ble Court pertained to regularization of various structures in Bandra, Goregaon, Boriveli, and Pydhonie apart from the top 17 floors of Gaurav Gagan, a 24-storeyed building in Kandiveli (West).

The Hon'ble High Court further ruled that it cannot be said as a matter of general rule that unauthorized constructions must be regularized if the floor space index (FSI) is available or can be generated in the form of transfer of development rights (TDR) from other sources by the builder. Although section 53(1) of the Maharashtra Regional Town Planning Act provides for regularization of unauthorized structures, the indiscriminate regularization through TDR or FSI can have disastrous consequences. Before the authorities take any decision about regularization they must not only consider the alleged hardship to individual flat purchasers but also the interest of those living in the neighbourhood and the public at large.

TAX DEDUCTION ON HOME LOANS INTEREST

                   TAX DEDUCTION ON HOME LOANS INTEREST
                                                                       
   
Incentives are offered under the Income tax Act on the investment in housing properties. Incentives come by way of deduction of payment of interest on the borrowed amount to buy or construct the house. Provisions relating to such deductions are provided in Section 24 of the Income Tax Act. The interest paid on a housing loan can be deducted from out of the taxable income of an Assessee according to this Section. The interest is permitted both on an accrual basis or due basis even if it is not actually paid in the year of accounting. To claim the deduction, the Assessee has to present a certificate from the Lender to whom the interest has to be paid on the borrowed capital pointing out the amount of interest paid or payable. The money should have been borrowed for acquiring the property or for constructing the property or repair of the property. Interest paid on a new loan taken to repay another existing loan is also permitted. The amount can be deducted in five equal installments starting from the previous year in which the house is acquired or built.

The first installment has to be deducted in the year of completion of property construction or the property is acquired and the remaining four installments in the four following years. Deduction for the full year is allowed even if one day is left in the year.

The maximum amount that can be deducted is Rs.1.5 lakhs. The money should have been borrowed on or following April 1, 1999 for acquiring it or for the construction. It is necessary that such acquisition or construction should have been finished within three years from the end of the financial year, in which the capital was borrowed. It has to be certified by the Lender that the interest is payable for the loan advanced for acquiring or constructing the house.

The deduction amount is limited to Rs.30, 000 if the money has been borrowed prior to April 1, 1999.

The date when the construction was started is not important. It is important only when the construction is completed within three years from the end of the financial year in which the money was borrowed. It is also not necessary that the whole cost to be financed though loan. Any portion of the cost of the house can be financed through loan.

It is advisable for purposes of tax to borrow and build or purchase instead of using one's own fund. The reason is that, if one uses his own fund he will not get any tax deduction from his total income.

For More

Monday, 4 April 2016

PURCHASERS OF APARTMENT


People with different culture, taste and habits living in separate dwelling units situate within a compound is not new to the country as it was prevalent in the past under the name and style as Vatara houses wherein small dwelling units were constructed within a compound for occupation and use by different families as their residence.

Vatara houses were constructed in horizontal or in L shape rows with single storey structures unlike the present day multiple storey vertical apartments.


Apartment culture, though of recent origin, has gained tremendous acceptance by the people in a very short time. Generally, it is seen that in apartments, people of different back- grounds, origin and culture live in good harmony and brotherhood. Shalimar Apartment, built in early seventies was probably the first Apartment that was constructed in Bangalore. Apartment culture further gained acceptance in early eighties when several apartments were built in Malleshwaram and other places. Since-then construction of apartments is in full swing in Bangalore and a large number of reputed builders and Promoters are busily engaged in the development of jlifferent Apartment Projects in and round Bangalore to meet the ever increasing demand for commer- cial and residential apartments.


Apartments have certain advantages in comparison with the independent houses. The first and foremost advantage the purchaser of an apartment will enjoy is that he need not have to worry about the issues like obtaining plan sanctions, finding a building contractor, supervising the construction work, obtaining basic amenities such as water, power, sewerage facilities for the building and so on which is taken care of by the Developer. The purchaser of apartment need not have to worry for any civic problems which he may encounter after his occupation of the apartment, since these problems are tackled by the Apartment Owners Associationl Builder for which a nominal charges are levied.

The next advantage an apartment owner gets would be the social harmony he would get due to community living. A sort of bondage is developed amongst the residents of apartments.
Further, for the exclusive use of apartment owners/occupants almost all the apartments now-a-days, do have facilities like gym, health-club, recreational center, sports club, swimming pool, private security system within the premises for which again a nominal fee is charged.


Even though living in apartments do have many advantages, they are not totally free from disadvantages. A Person who lives in an apartment generally is deprived of his privacy. Further, the apartment owner is prevented from carrying out any major addition, alteration or modification to his apartment to suit his needs. All such repairs, alterations and modifications are to be carried out with least inconvenience to other apartment owners and any damage or loss caused to the other apartment owners are to be compensated. The amount collected by the Apartment Owners Association to meet the expenses for general maintenance and upkeep may be more than what a person would have spent had he owned an independent house and could be much more than what is required for such maintenance. There is every likelihood of such a common fund being misused by the office bearers of the Association or over which there could be some misunderstanding amongst the apartment owners leading to unsavoury situation.

Apartments would fetch a much lower price compared to an independent house during its second sale. Further, any dilapidated single apartment would fetch no buyers since the land on which such apartment is built is owned by all the apartment owners and the seller does not have the exclusive ownership right over the land on which such apartment is situate. On the contrary, a dilapidated independent house would generally get prospective buyers irrespective of the condition of the structure since new structures could be put on such sites after demolishing the existing ones and the seller of such a dilapidated house will transfer his right, title and ownership of the land as well.

How to proceed?

As in the case of purchase of any other property, verification of ownership title is one of the pre-requisites for purchase of an apartment also. Though the builder of apartments provides legal opinion given by his advocate regarding subsistence of marketable and valid title of the vendors, it is always better that the intending purchaser of an apartment gets the title report of the property scrutinized from an advocate of his choice having vast knowledge and experience in property dealings. The legal scrutiny report shall contain detailed information regarding the origin, flow of title, present status of the owner, validity of the OPA, Joint Venture, if any, entered into between the owner and the Developer.

Another very important aspect which requires consideration is to ascertain whether the approval for construction of apartments and the plan has been obtained form the competent authority and to find out whether commencement and completion certificates have been issued by such an authority.

Location of the building is another important aspect which one has to consider before purchasing an apartment. This is mainly because any building which has no proper access to main roads with insufficient public transport and other civic amenities such as water, electricity supply, proper, sanitation, parks, market place, hospitals, schools, etc. would put the purchaser of flat to a great hardship and inconvenience.

Apart from all these, the previous history and record of the Builder is necessary to be verified for which purpose, it is always advisable to visit some of the4 projects executed by the builder in advance.


For grant of approval for building construction and the plans, different authorities are delegated with this power under different statutes. While, the village Panchayats are empowered to give license for construction of building consisting of ground and first floor, the City Municipal Corporation can approve plans for ground plus three upper floors. The BBMP or BDA or any other concerned Town Planning Authority can approve building plans of land for construction of multistoried buildings apart from constructing an independent house. In the case of high rise buildings consisting of more than four floors, No Objection Certificates form BWSSB, BESCOM, Fire force authority, BSNL, Airport Authority of India and Karnataka State Pollution Control Board are to be compulsorily obtained.

It must be kept in mind that anyone who violates the building bye-laws and zonal regulations would expose himself to the risk of demolition of such structure any time in the future.

Conveyance/Sale Deed

Normally, before purchase of an apartment, a sale agreement is executed by the Owner, [represented by the OPA Holder where there exists a OPA holder] and the Builder, agreeing to sell an undivided share in the land in favour of the intending purchaser. While at the same time, a construction agreement is also executed by the Builder in favour of the intending purchaser agreeing to construct an apartment for him. Once construction of apartment is complete, a sale deed is executed jointly by the vendor of the land and the builder/Promoter in accordance with the terms and conditions of the Joint Development Agreement, if any, in favour of the purchaser. The sale deed specifically recites the duties and responsibilities of the buyer and the seller. As regards sale consideration, it is arrived at upon consideration of the various aspects such as location, specification of the work, carpet area and percentage of Carpet area to Super Built up Area and as agreed to between the parties.

Undivided Share of Land

Undivided share is the percentage of share conveyed in the total land along with the apartment to the purchaser. This percentage depends upon the built up area of an apartment and the actual extent of land upon which the apartments are constructed. As the built up area increase the undivided share over the land also increases.

Super Built-Up Area

Super built up area is the saleable area generally applicable to apartments. Super built up area consists of actual flat area plus proportionate common areas like staircase cum verandah, balcony, lift area and other common areas etc.

Since the price of an apartment depends upon the super built up area, it is advisable for the purchaser to have some knowledge about Carpet area, plinth area and super built up area before purchase of an apartment. Generally super built up area should not be more than 25% of the carpet area.

Registration expenses

It is obligatory on the part of the purchaser to bear the expenses incurred towards stamp duty, registration charges and other incidental expenses to be incurred in connection with the registra- tion of the apartment. Infact, the Builders are collecting Sales tax, service tax, statutory deposits for Bescom and BWSSB. 

Registered sale deed

Registered sale deed is the document which establishes ownership title of the apartment in favour of the purchaser. While making the Registration of Sale Deed, certain factors need to be verified, such as: Operative words of the Sale Deed; Consideration passing details; Devolution of the Property conveyed; Flow of title of the Property to the Vendor; Indemnity Clauses, etc. .

Further, the property which you intend the purchase is to be properly conveyed to you along with undivided share of land, besides Super built-up area.  Generally, in the Apartment land owners will be more than one person, in such cases, they have to be represented by the Developer being the Registered General Power of Attorney holder for the Developer’s share of land; and in case of Owner’s share of land, basing on the Sharing Agreement, they cannot convey the flat individually and instead all the owners jointly only can convey the property because it being undivided share of land and right of ownership of ingress and egress to be conveyed effectively.  Further, the Sharing Agreement is just an agreement and it cannot convey any ownership rights. Relying on the sale deed the concerned Revenue authorities issue other supporting documents of title such as Khatha Endorsement, Khatha Extract and the Tax paid receipts.

Registration under Apartment Owners' association

After completion of construction and handing over of the apartments to the purchasers, the owners of such apartments are required to form an association for the general well-being of the owners or residents of the apartments and for maintenance of common areas. Upon formation of such an association, the builder is duty bound to hand over originals of all the relevant title deeds, detailed drawings of electrical, water and sanitary lines to enable the Association to utilize the same for the common good whenever required. The Apartment Owners’ Association can be formed either under the Karnataka Apartment Owners’ Association Act or Karnataka Societies Act.

A word of caution


Do not go by glossy advertisements and tall claims of the builder. There are several instances wherein the apartments purchased by a few are inflicted with certain latent defects which remain unattended to by the builder when once the sale transaction is complete pushing the purchaser to suffer both in terms of comfort and finance. There are many reputed builders available in the market with impressive track records. Choose anyone of them and have a peaceful enjoyment of your apartment.

For More

Saturday, 2 April 2016

SUPREME COURT DECISION ON ‘WILL’

                       




Execution of a Will is required to be proved in terms of the provisions of Section 63(c) of the Indian Succession Act and Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act.

In Janki Narayan Bhoir v. Narayan Namdeo Kadam, [(2003) 2 SCC 91], while dealing with the question elaborately, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held as under:

“To say Will has been duly executed, the requirement mentioned in Clauses (a), (b) and (c) of Section 63 of the  Succession Act are to be complied with i.e., (a) the testator has to sign or affix his mark to the will, or it has got to be signed by some other person in his presence and by his direction; (b) that the signature or mark of the testator, or the signature of the person signing at his direction, has to appear at a place form which it could appear that by that mark or signature the document is intended to have effect as a will; (c) the most important point with which we are presently concerned in this appeal, is that the will has to be attested by two or more witnesses and each of these witnesses must have seen the testator sign or affix his mark to the Will, or must have seen some other person sign the Will in the presence and by the direction of the testator, or must have received from the testator a personal acknowledgement of signature or mark, or of the signature of such other person, and each of the 11 witnesses has to sign the Will in the presence of the testator."

As regards compliance of the provision of Section 68 of the Evidence Act, it was opined :

"In a way, Section 68 gives a concession to those who want to prove and establish a will in a Court of law by examining at least one attesting witness even though will has to be attested at least by two witnesses mandatorily under Section 63 of the Succession Act. But what is significant and to be noted is that one attesting witness examined should be in a position to prove the execution of a will. To put in other words, if one attesting witness can prove execution of the will in terms of Clause (c) of Section 63, viz., attestation by two attesting witnesses in the manner contemplated therein, the examination of other attesting witness can be dispensed with. The one attesting witness examined, in his evidence has to satisfy the attestation of a will by him and the other attesting witness in order to prove there was due execution of the will. If the attesting witness examined besides his attestation does not, in his evidence, satisfy the requirements of attention of the will by other witness also it falls short of attestation of will at least by two witnesses for the simple reason that the execution of the will does not merely mean the signing of it by the testator but it means fulfilling and proof of all the formalities required under Section 63 of the Succession Act. Where one attesting witness examined to prove the will under Section 68 of the Evidence Act fails to prove the due execution of the will then the other available attesting witness has to be called to supplement his evidence to make it complete in all respects. Where one attesting witness is examined and he fails to prove the attestation of the will by the other witness there will be deficiency in meeting the mandatory requirements of Section 68 of the Evidence Act."

More





Proposed Land Acquisition Law – whether boon or bane?






Acquisition of land for public utility shall always have social, economic and political repercussions and it is not an exception now. In spite of the fact that our country is predominantly agricultural sector based, if our country need to grow, the growth has to be from non-agricultural sector such as manufacturing and services, for which there is no alternative other than to depend on the land to provide much needed infrastructure development.
With this idea, Special Economic Zones (SEZs) were created; however, this concept did not work out effectively for obvious reasons, and there was a huge controversy over the land acquisition, resulting in several projects coming to a standstill. 
Recent studies reveal that delays in land acquisition is threatening to endanger investments in near term and may lead to create negative impact on our country’s economic growth, job opportunities and tax collection. 
In order to ensure that the owner of the land under acquisition shall have a right to fair compensation and the entire process will take place in a transparent manner, the Government brought into existence the ‘Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition Bill 2013”. In this, it is said to have features like compensation for the owners to the extent of four times the market value in rural areas and twice in case of urban areas, and it provides that consent of 80% of the displaced owners is required in case of acquisition for private or public sector. Even though these features appear to be attractive for the beneficiaries, there are some other features associated with the bill, such as, no consent required in case of acquisition for PSUs, and that the Government can temporarily acquire land for three years and that there would be no provision for rehabilitation and resettlement in such cases, etc. 
No doubt this proposed Law may be much advanced and fair replacement to the existing Law, but it is all the more important to ensure that the proposed Law is properly implemented for positive results. 
Therefore, one has to wait and watch over a period of time to understand whether the proposed Law will really offer what it promised and will lay the road for fast track infrastructure development or simply remain beating round the bush.  


for more 

Friday, 1 April 2016

Querries on Property matters






Certain hidden facts like pending cases, prior agreements, government notifications of the property cannot be traced out easily by verification of the documents.  How can these hidden factors be uncovered, and what should a purchaser do to protect himself against these hidden factors?
Rajan Kalyan, JP Nagar, Bangalore

Generally seller hands over the copies of the property documents to the purchaser to examine the title.  Such documents contain only title documents, which may be cross-checked in the sub registrar’s Office.  But they do not disclose any pending litigations, prior agreements which are not registered and government notifications.  As such, the Purchaser should be very cautious and make arrangements for thorough search of records at the concerned jurisdictional Courts to rule out the possibility of any pending cases and also in offices of Urban Development Authorities such as : BDA, BMRDA, KIADB, KHB, High way and other planning authorities etc., to rule out the acquisition notifications, if any.

Further, it would be difficult to verify any existing prior agreements or arrangements which are not registered.  As such, proper enquiries with owner of the property, and also with neighbours may be helpful.  It would always be better to register the sale agreement and get the property registered at the earliest.  Above all, Paper publication of the intention of the Purchaser to buy particular property would help the purchaser to a certain extent.  

What is Paper publication? How does it benefit the purchaser
Shenoy, Rajajinagar, Bangalore

Though the Paper Publication may not be a statutory requirement, yet the idea of getting a notice published in the widely circulated newspaper in the locality, is to elicit the information from the general public that a bona fide purchaser is intending to purchase the property from its owner.  Besides this, the paper notification also invites objections from various interested persons with documentary evidence in support of their claim within the specific period.

Even after issuance of such paper notification, a person said to have his claim to the property does not lose his rights just because he could not disclose his rights in response to such paper notification within the given time. 

I am not able to understand the difference between Khatha Certificate and Khatha extract.  Would you please enlighten me on this ? Could you also brief me about the importance of Encumbrance Certificate ?
Veeresh, Uttarahalli

Khatha is a revenue record maintained by the municipal authorities in respect of a property standing in the name of a particular person for purposes of assessment and collection of property tax.  As it is a secondary document in the absence of primary documents like Sale Deed, Gift Deed, Partition Deed, Release Deed, Will, Grant etc., however it does not establish the title in its totality. 

Khatha Certificate is a Certificate issued by the Municipal authority Office confirming that the Khatha of a particular property stands in the name of a particular person/s.

Khatha Extract is an Extract of the tax assessment register maintained at Municipal Office giving complete details of the property like: Area of the site, building, property tax levied, cess and total tax payable, name of the previous and present owner of the property, etc. 
Encumbrance Certificate is issued by Sub Registrar Offices for a specific period as required by the applicant.  It contain the details of the property like: Sy. No. House No. boundaries, and encumbrances on such property like: Sale, Gift, transfer, mortgage, if any, which are registered at the said sub registrar’s office.  However, the Encumbrance Certificate do not reflect the encumbrance transactions of deeds which are not registered. 

What is the procedure for Khatha transfer and how do we know that the Khatha transfer Certificate is genuine and original
Sreenivasa Prasad, Jayanagar, Bangalore

Transfer of Khatha of property to your name is to be done by the concerned jurisdictional revenue authority under whose jurisdiction the property is situated.  For this purpose, you have to apply for transfer of khatha in a duly filled Khatha Transfer application duly signed by both the Seller as well as Purchaser i.e., yourself, and enclose a copy of the registered Sale Deed, latest tax paid receipt and up to date encumbrance certificate along with the necessary fee. 

Thereafter, the authorities do acknowledge receipt of the application and indicate the date by which the process will be completed; however, the entire process is to be required to be completed within 45 days.  Meanwhile, the authorities may also call for certain additional information / document etc., if felt necessary for verification and confirmation.  Thereafter, the Khatha of the property would be transferred into your name and an endorsement will be issued in your name to this effect.  Thereafter, tax paid receipts on such property would be issued in your name, which show that the said property stands in your name. 

As regards ascertaining whether the Khatha Certificate issued is genuine and original or not, the Khatha Certificate is usually issued by the concerned jurisdictional Corporation Office and as such you may directly visit such office and obtain the same to confirm its genuineness and originality.      

Do the financial institutions permit the transfer of loan from one institution to other and what is the fee charged for such transfer and whether it would be better to transfer from one institution to other ?
Sadashiva murthy, Hosakote

Financial Institutions allow the transfer of loan from one institution to another even though they don’t want their existing loan accounts to be taken over by other institutions.  However, such institution which allow transfer of loan account may charge foreclosure charges for such transaction in order to minimize such transfer of loan accounts.  It is left to the customer as to when to transfer the loan from one institution to another taking into consideration various factors of which the major point is to look into the rate of interest besides other benefits which he would get from other institution on such transfer.  After obtaining in-principle approval from the taking over institution or bank, such transfer of loan account is possible. 

For  More information

11 MONTH LEASE DEED MUST BE REGISTERED



HC says if unregistered, such deeds cannot be ‘received as evidence of any transaction affecting the property’
The common practice of lease deeds (including rental agreements) between property owners and tenants for 11 months to avoid registering the deed is not the right thing to do. The high court of Karnataka has held that deeds where the term of the lease stated does not exceed one year alaso have to be registered.
In a particular case, the court held that such unregistered deeds cannot be received as evidence of any dispute between the tenant and property owner, unregistered deeds will only serve collateral purpose in courts and not as evidence.
Abdul Rasheed, a tailor and tenant of Srinivas, a retired district judge, approached the HC against a lower court order that refused to accept as evidence four unregistered lease deeds. Justice HG Ramesh probed the question “Whether a lease deed, where the term of lease stated therein does not exceed one year, requires to be registered under the Registration Act, 1908”.
In a significant order that comes as a surprise to common perception of this aspect of law, the courtheld, “In law, the lease deeds of the afore to be registered and therefore, such unregistered lease deeds cannot be received as evidence of any transaction affecting the property.”
Rasheed in his petition claimed that under the Act, if the term of the lease was less than one year, there was no need for registration.
Section 107 of the Act says, “ A lease of immovable property from year to year, or for any term exceeding one year or reserving a yearly rent, can be made only by a registered instrument.” However, the HC order stressed the second paragraph of the section 107 which says, “All other leases of immovable property may be made either by a registered instrument or by oralagreement accompanied by delivery of possession.” Section 49 of the Act says that documents that need to be registered but are not cannot “be received as evidence of any transaction affecting such property.” The court held that the second paragraph of section makes it mandatory for lease deeds less than one year to be registered if they are not just oral. Therefore under section 49, they become inadmissible in court if not registered.
However, the court gave liberty to Rasheed to approach the trial court with the same documents specifically stating that they are for ‘collateral purpose’ only. Therefore unregistered lease agreements can be used only as collaborative evidence in court. The order renders most rental agreements invalid as evidence in court ifa dispute arises between the lessor and lessee.
 “Usually in disputes about rents, the rent receipts are produced as evidence. It is mostly residential properties that are registered for 11 months. Commercial properties usually have a longer lease agreement. The order is an eye-opener. In court, property owners do not produce the lease agreements as they are unregistered. If it is impounded by the court, they  will end up paying 11 times the stamp duty. This order may lead to a fresh struggle between house owners and tenants.”


For More